Binary options vs regular options: a bet with a fixed payout vs a contract that scales
A binary option asks one yes-or-no question and pays a fixed amount if you're right. A regular option is worth more the further price moves past the strike. To learn options, learn regular ones. Treat an "up or down" app from an unknown company as a likely scam: regulators have warned about them for years.
The short answer
A binary option pays a fixed amount if a yes-or-no question comes true, like "will this stock be above $102 at 4 p.m.?" If yes, you get the full payout. If no, you lose what you paid. A move of 1 cent past the line pays the same as a move of $10.
A regular option, like a Call option, gives you the right to buy 100 shares at the strike. The further the stock moves past the strike, the more it's worth.
If you want to learn options, learn regular options on a regulated exchange. A binary only makes sense on a regulated exchange, and only if you understand that a small move and a huge move pay the same. Treat any app selling "up or down in 60 seconds" from an unknown company as a likely scam.
Side by side
| Binary option | Regular option | |
|---|---|---|
| Payout | Fixed amount, or nothing | Grows with the move past the strike |
| Most you can lose (buyer) | What you paid | What you paid |
| Time frames | Often minutes to a day | Days to years |
| Can you sell it early? | Sometimes | Yes, on any trading day |
| Where it trades | A few regulated exchanges, many offshore apps | Regulated options exchanges |
| Underlying shares | Never delivered | Usually 100 shares |
| Who sets the price | Often the platform itself | Buyers and sellers on an exchange |
The last row is the quiet problem. On many binary apps, the company that takes your bet is also the one that decides the price and whether you won.
One move, both ways
A made-up stock trades at $100. You think it will rise by Friday. You have $150 to spend (hypothetical, round numbers).
- Binary: "Above $102 on Friday" costs $50 and pays $100 if yes. You buy three for $150. They pay $300 if yes, $0 if no.
- Regular call: one $102 call costs $1.50 a share, or $150 for the contract.
What you have at Friday's close:
| Stock on Friday | Three binaries | One $102 call |
|---|---|---|
| $101 | −$150 | −$150 |
| $103 | +$150 | −$50 |
| $105 | +$150 | +$150 |
| $110 | +$150 | +$650 |
How it works:
- At $103, the binaries pay $300 for a $150 cost. The call is worth $1 a share, $100, for a $50 loss.
- At $110, the binaries still pay $300. The call is worth $8 a share, $800, for a $650 gain.
- At $101, both lose everything.
So binaries pay more on a small move and cap you on a big one. The call needs a bigger move to pay, and keeps paying.
The math inside an "up or down" app
Many binary apps don't price contracts like the example above. They offer a payout like "win 80%, lose 100%" (hypothetical figures; each app sets its own).
Bet $100. Win and you get your $100 back plus $80. Lose and the $100 is gone. To break even, you have to be right 100 ÷ 180 = about 56% of the time. On a 60-second or 5-minute move, that's close to a coin flip that you're paying to take. The house edge is built in before you start.
Why regulators warn about binary options
Securities and commodities regulators in the US, Canada and elsewhere have warned the public about binary options for years. The warnings focus on platforms run from outside the country that aren't registered to sell to you. The problems they describe, in general terms:
- the platform won't let you withdraw your money, or adds conditions after you deposit;
- bonuses that lock your money in until you trade a huge amount;
- prices or results that the platform itself controls;
- identity theft, after you send copies of ID "to verify your account";
- pressure from a "broker" or "account manager" to deposit more.
Canada's securities regulators have restricted binary options sold to individuals. In the US, binary contracts are legal on a small number of regulated exchanges. A company that isn't one of those, and isn't registered where you live, is a red flag.
How to tell a regulated binary from an app
| Sign | Regulated exchange | Likely scam |
|---|---|---|
| Registration | You can look it up with a regulator | Vague, or only an overseas license |
| Who's on the other side | Other traders, through the exchange | The platform itself |
| Withdrawals | Normal bank transfers | Delays, fees, "bonus" conditions |
| Marketing | Plain contract specs | Ads showing big wins and lifestyles |
| Contact | No cold calls | A "broker" calls you |
Which one to pick
| You want | Lean toward |
|---|---|
| To learn how options work | Regular options |
| A payout that grows if you're very right | Regular options |
| A fixed yes-or-no bet on an event | A binary on a regulated exchange only |
| Fast trades on an app from an ad | Neither; walk away |
Regular options aren't only for betting on direction. Many people sell them instead and collect the premium; see the wheel strategy. For every main options strategy in one table, see the options strategy comparison chart.
Questions
Are binary options legal?
In the US, on a small number of regulated exchanges. Many binary apps advertised online aren't registered to sell to you, and regulators have warned about them. Canada has restricted binary options for individuals.
Are binary options the same as regular options?
No. A binary pays a fixed amount or nothing. A regular option is worth more the further price moves past the strike, and usually covers 100 shares.
Why do binary options lose money for so many people?
Many apps pay less when you win than you lose when you're wrong, so you need to be right well over half the time just to break even.
How do I check a platform?
Look it up with your country's securities or commodities regulator. If you can't find it there, don't send money.
The Options Wheel System · for StructureX members
Learn the whole wheel, step by step. Use it for life.
44 plain-English modules take you from zero to running the wheel: covered calls, cash-secured puts, assignment, rolling, the math and the risk rules. A scored quiz after every part. Members of StructureX Foundations, my 50-lesson course, add it in one click, with the AI Research Desk.
See What’s Inside the Course $34.99 a month · Cancel anytimeFollow along