Covered calls vs bonds for income: why one can't replace the other
Bonds pay you interest and return your money at the end, as long as the borrower pays. Covered calls pay you a premium while you keep all the risk of the stock. Use bonds for money you need on a set date. Use covered calls only on stock you'd hold through a crash anyway.
The short answer
A Bond is a loan. You lend money, you get interest on a schedule, and you get the loan amount back on a set date. If you hold it to that date and the borrower pays, a falling market doesn't change what you get back.
A Covered call is a deal on stock you own. You sell someone the right to buy your shares at a set price, and they pay you a premium. You keep every dollar of the stock's drop.
So pick bonds for the part of your money that has to be there on a date. Pick covered calls for money that's already in stocks and can ride a crash. Swapping one for the other trades a small, steady payment for stock risk.
Side by side
| Bond ladder | Covered calls on an index fund | |
|---|---|---|
| What you own | Loans to a government or company | Shares of a stock fund |
| What pays you | Interest | Option premium + dividends |
| Money back at the end? | Yes, if held and the borrower pays | No end date, worth whatever the fund is |
| In a crash | Interest keeps coming | You own the falling shares |
| In a big rally | Interest only | Gains capped at the strike |
| Main risk | Borrower defaults, rates rise | The stock market falls |
A bond ladder is a set of bonds that come due one after another, say one each year for five years. When one comes due, you get the money back and can buy a new one.
Why call premium isn't bond interest
Bond interest is rent for your money. The borrower uses your money, pays you for it, and promises to hand it back on a set date.
Call premium is a payment for a promise you make: to sell your shares at the strike, even if they go far higher. The premium pays you for giving up the upside. It does nothing for the downside. The stock can fall 40% while you collect premium every month.
That's the trap in calling both "income". One comes with your money back. The other comes with your money at risk.
One hypothetical $50,000, two ways
All numbers here are hypothetical and round.
- Bonds: a five-rung ladder, $10,000 per rung, each paying 4% interest. That's $2,000 for the year.
- Covered calls: $50,000 in an index fund. You sell calls through the year and collect $3,000 in premium in total. Dividends are left out to keep it simple.
Three possible years:
| Year | Bond ladder | Covered calls: shares | Covered calls: premium | Covered calls: total |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Calm, index up 4% | +$2,000 | +$2,000 | +$3,000 | +$5,000 |
| Strong, index up 25% | +$2,000 | +$4,000 (capped) | +$3,000 | +$7,000 |
| Crash, index down 35% | +$2,000 | −$17,500 | +$3,000 | −$14,500 |
In the calm year, covered calls paid more. In the strong year, the calls capped you at +$4,000 of a $12,500 rise, but you still beat the bonds. Then the crash year: the bond ladder ends at about $52,000, and the covered call account ends at $35,500.
That crash row is the whole page. $3,000 of premium against a $17,500 drop is the trade you made to collect it.
Bond prices can fall too. When rates rise, older bonds with lower interest are worth less if you sell them early. In 2022 bond prices fell hard; see the 2022 bond crash. But a ladder you hold until each rung comes due still pays back each rung in full, as long as the borrower pays. Stocks have no such date.
Where covered calls do fit
Covered calls make sense on shares you already planned to hold through a crash anyway. Then the premium is extra, and the cap is the price of it. That's the honest way to think about a covered call strategy, and the share-owning half of the wheel strategy.
They don't make sense as a bond replacement for money you need for a house, a tuition bill or next year's living costs.
Which one to pick
| Your money is for | Lean toward |
|---|---|
| A bill due on a known date | Bonds or bills |
| Money you won't touch for years, already in stocks | Covered calls on part of it |
| A steady payment that can't drop with stocks | Bonds |
| More cash flow from shares you'd hold anyway | Covered calls |
| Both | A mix, sized so a crash doesn't hit the money you need |
In Canada, both bonds and covered calls are widely allowed in a TFSA or RRSP. Options permissions differ by broker, so check before you plan around them.
To see covered calls next to every other way to sell options, use the options strategy comparison chart. If you hold cash for puts, cash-secured puts vs T-bills runs that choice.
Questions
Are covered calls safer than stocks?
A little. The premium softens a drop. But you still own the shares, so a big fall still hits you, and you give up big gains in return.
Can covered calls replace the bonds in my portfolio?
Not for the same job. Bonds give your money back on a date if the borrower pays. Covered calls leave you with full stock risk.
Why do covered calls pay more than bonds?
Because you take more risk. The premium pays you for capping your gains while you keep every dollar of the drop.
Do bonds lose money?
Their prices can fall when rates rise, and a borrower can fail to pay. Held to the end with a borrower that pays, a bond returns its face value.
The Options Wheel System · for StructureX members
Learn the whole wheel, step by step. Use it for life.
44 plain-English modules take you from zero to running the wheel: covered calls, cash-secured puts, assignment, rolling, the math and the risk rules. A scored quiz after every part. Members of StructureX Foundations, my 50-lesson course, add it in one click, with the AI Research Desk.
See What’s Inside the Course $34.99 a month · Cancel anytimeFollow along