Employee stock options vs trading options: what's the difference?
Employee stock options are part of your pay: your company grants them, and they often take years to vest. Trading options are contracts you buy or sell on an exchange any day. Plan employee options as part of your pay. Before you sell calls on company shares, check your company's trading policy.
The short answer
Employee stock options are granted by your employer. They let you buy company shares at a set price, called the strike or exercise price, once they vest. You don't pay for them. You can't sell them to anyone. When you exercise, you pay the company the strike and get new shares.
Trading options are listed contracts, like a Call option, that anyone with an approved account can buy or sell. You pay a premium for them or get paid one. Each usually covers 100 shares, and you can close them on any trading day.
Treat employee options as part of your pay and plan when to exercise and sell. Treat trading options as a separate tool. If you already hold company shares and want to sell calls on them, check your company's trading policy first. Many companies limit or ban it for employees.
Side by side
| Employee stock options | Trading options | |
|---|---|---|
| Who creates them | Your employer | Traders on an exchange |
| What you pay | Nothing to receive them | The premium |
| Can you sell the option? | No | Yes, any trading day |
| Waiting period | A vesting schedule, often years | None |
| Life | Often many years | Days to a few years |
| On exercise | You pay the company, new shares are created | Shares change hands between traders |
| If you leave the job | Often a short window to exercise, check your plan | Nothing changes |
| Tax | Special employee rules, often at exercise | Usual investment rules |
One worked example, both ways
You work at a made-up company, Copperline Software. You hold 1,000 vested options with a $20 strike. The stock is $30 (hypothetical, round numbers).
Compare them with a trader who buys the same exposure on an exchange: ten listed $20 calls at $11 each, a cost of $11 × 100 × 10 = $11,000.
| Stock price at the end | 1,000 employee options (cost $0) | Ten $20 listed calls (cost $11,000) |
|---|---|---|
| $40 | Worth $20,000 | +$9,000 |
| $30 | Worth $10,000 | −$1,000 |
| $18 | Worth $0 | −$11,000 |
The payoff shape is the same: $1 above the strike is worth $1 a share. The difference is the cost. You got your options as pay. The trader paid $11,000, including $1 a share of time value, so they lose money at $30 even though the calls are in the money.
But note the bottom row for the employee too. At $18, options that looked like $10,000 are worth nothing. If your pay, your options and your shares all depend on one company, one bad year hits all three at once.
Can I sell covered calls on my company shares?
This is the question most pages skip. A Covered call means owning 100 shares and selling a call on them for a premium. On shares you own outright, it's possible at a broker. Three things get in the way:
- Your company's trading policy. Many companies ban employees, or at least officers and insiders, from trading options on company stock, including covered calls. Read the policy, or ask the legal team, before you place anything.
- Blackout windows. Most companies block trading by many employees in the weeks around earnings. An open call can be assigned during a blackout, which can put you in a spot your policy doesn't allow.
- Inside information. Trading on news the public doesn't have yet is Insider trading, whether you use shares or options. If you know something, you can't trade on it.
One more practical point: your employee options can't back a call. Brokers generally don't count options you haven't exercised as cover. Only shares in the account count.
If those checks pass, the trade works like any covered call: you collect a premium and agree to sell at the strike. See the covered call strategy guide and the wheel strategy for how strikes and timing work.
Taxes, in general terms
Employee options have their own tax rules in both the US and Canada, and they often apply when you exercise, not only when you sell. In the US, the type of option your plan grants changes the treatment. In Canada, the gain at exercise is usually treated as employment income, with its own rules. Your plan documents, the IRS and the CRA are where to check. When you later sell shares bought at different times, FIFO vs specific identification decides which shares count as sold in the US.
Which one to pick
| Your situation | What to do |
|---|---|
| You have vested options | Plan when to exercise and when to sell |
| You hold company shares and want premium | Read the trading policy first |
| You're in a blackout window | No new trades in company stock |
| Most of your wealth is in your employer | Think about spreading it out before adding options |
| You want to learn options | Practice on other stocks, not your employer's |
For every options strategy in one table, see the options strategy comparison chart.
Questions
Can I sell my employee stock options?
Usually not. They can't be transferred. You exercise them and then sell the shares, or let them expire.
Are employee stock options taxed like trading options?
No. They have their own rules, often at exercise. Check your plan documents and the IRS or CRA.
Can I sell covered calls on company stock?
Only on shares you own, and only if your company's trading policy allows it. Many policies limit or ban options on company stock.
What happens to my options if I quit?
Unvested options usually end. Vested ones often must be exercised within a set window. Your plan says how long.
The Options Wheel System · for StructureX members
Learn the whole wheel, step by step. Use it for life.
44 plain-English modules take you from zero to running the wheel: covered calls, cash-secured puts, assignment, rolling, the math and the risk rules. A scored quiz after every part. Members of StructureX Foundations, my 50-lesson course, add it in one click, with the AI Research Desk.
See What’s Inside the Course $34.99 a month · Cancel anytimeFollow along