Equal weight vs market cap weighted: how does your money get split?
A market cap weighted index puts more money in bigger companies. An equal weight index puts the same amount in each one. The split decides how much one giant company can move your whole fund.
The short answer
Pick market cap weight if you want the cheapest, simplest way to own the market as it is, biggest companies and all. Pick equal weight if you don't want a few giants to decide most of your result, and you accept more trading and usually a higher fee to get that.
- Market cap weight: each company's share of the fund matches its size. Market cap is the share price times the number of shares. Most big US indexes, like the S&P 500, work this way.
- Equal weight: every company gets the same slice, no matter how big. The fund has to sell winners and buy losers on a schedule to keep the slices equal.
Side by side
| Market cap weight | Equal weight | |
|---|---|---|
| Biggest company's slice | Its share of the total size | Same as every other company |
| Who moves the index most | The giants | Every company equally |
| Trading needed | Very little, it adjusts by itself | Regular rebalancing |
| Rebalancing cost | Close to none | The spread on every trade, plus more taxable gains in a taxable account |
| Typical cost | Usually lower | Usually higher |
| Leans toward | Large companies | Smaller and mid-size companies |
| When one giant falls | You feel it a lot | You feel it a little |
| When one giant soars | You get a lot of it | You get a little of it |
A three-stock index, built both ways
A made-up index of three companies (hypothetical numbers, not a trade idea).
| Company | Market cap | Cap weight | Equal weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| Titan Corp | $700B | 70% | 33.3% |
| Midway Inc | $200B | 20% | 33.3% |
| Sprout Co | $100B | 10% | 33.3% |
| Total | $1,000B | 100% | 100% |
You put $9,000 into each version. In the cap weighted fund that's $6,300 in Titan, $1,800 in Midway and $900 in Sprout. In the equal weight fund it's $3,000 in each.
One week where the biggest stock drops
Titan falls 10%. Midway and Sprout each rise 5%.
| Company | Move | Cap weighted ($) | Equal weight ($) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Titan | −10% | $6,300 → −$630 | $3,000 → −$300 |
| Midway | +5% | $1,800 → +$90 | $3,000 → +$150 |
| Sprout | +5% | $900 → +$45 | $3,000 → +$150 |
| Week total | −$495 | $0 |
Check the math. Cap weighted: −630 + 90 + 45 = −$495, which is −5.5% of $9,000. The quick route agrees: 0.70 × −10 + 0.20 × 5 + 0.10 × 5 = −7 + 1 + 0.5 = −5.5%. Equal weight: −300 + 150 + 150 = $0.
Two of three companies went up, and the cap weighted fund still fell. Titan alone decided the week.
Now flip it. If Titan rises 10% and the other two fall 5%, the cap weighted fund is up 5.5% and the equal weight fund is flat again. Cap weight rides the giant both ways. Neither one is better every week. They just bet on different things.
The rebalancing step
After that week, the cap weighted fund does nothing. Titan is smaller now, so its weight shrank on its own. That's why cap weighted funds trade so little.
The equal weight fund is now uneven: $2,700 in Titan, $3,150 in Midway and $3,150 in Sprout, still $9,000 in total. To get back to $3,000 each, it sells $150 of Midway and $150 of Sprout and buys $300 of Titan.
That habit has two sides:
- It buys what fell and sells what rose, every time. If the fallen stock bounces, that helps. If it keeps falling, the fund keeps buying more of it.
- Every rebalance is trading, and trading has costs. That's part of why equal weight funds usually charge more.
What the rebalancing costs
How much a fund trades is called turnover. Equal weight has more of it, and it costs in two ways.
1. The spread. This rebalance sold $300 and bought $300, so $600 changed hands. Say each trade loses 0.10% to the Bid and ask spread (hypothetical). That's $0.60. Four rebalances like it in a year: $2.40. The cap weighted fund paid $0. Bigger moves between rebalances mean bigger trades and a bigger bill.
2. Taxes, in a taxable account. Selling Midway and Sprout after they rose locks in a gain. A fund that sells winners more often is more likely to pay out capital gains to its holders. You owe tax on that payout even if you never sold a share. Inside an IRA, Roth IRA, TFSA or RRSP, that part doesn't apply.
The same goes if you equal-weight your own stocks: you pay the spread and the tax yourself.
Equal weight funds rebalance on a set schedule, often every quarter. Check the fund's own page for its schedule and fee.
Which one fits you?
| Pick this | If you… |
|---|---|
| Market cap weight | want the simplest, lowest-cost way to own the market |
| Market cap weight | are fine with the biggest companies driving most of the result |
| Equal weight | worry about a few giants making up a big share of your fund |
| Equal weight | want more weight in smaller companies and accept more trading |
| Both, split | want some of each bet |
In Canada, both kinds of ETF can be held in a TFSA or RRSP. If you sell covered calls on an index fund, the weighting changes what you're writing calls against, so read the fund's top holdings first. See the wheel strategy, and for picking a strategy by outlook, the options strategy comparison chart.
Questions
Is the S&P 500 equal weighted?
No. The standard S&P 500 is weighted by market cap, adjusted for shares available to trade. There's a separate equal weight version, and funds that track it.
Which has done better, equal weight or cap weight?
It depends on the period. When the largest companies lead, cap weight tends to win. When smaller companies catch up, equal weight tends to win. No weighting wins every stretch.
Why does equal weight cost more?
It has to trade on a schedule to keep the slices equal. That trading costs money, and the fund's fee is usually higher than a plain cap weighted index fund's.
Does equal weight mean less risk?
It means less risk from any one giant. But it leans toward smaller companies, which can swing more. It's a different risk, not none.
Follow along