Free cash flow vs net income: which one tells the truth?
Net income is the profit on paper. Free cash flow is the cash left after the company pays to run and keep up the business. When the two point in different directions, believe the cash first, then find out why.
The short answer
Check both, but trust free cash flow when they disagree. Net income is profit by the accounting rules. It counts a sale the moment it's made, even if the customer hasn't paid yet. Free cash flow counts only cash that actually came in, minus the cash spent on equipment and buildings.
A company pays its bills, its debt and its dividend with cash, not with profit. So if profit is rising and cash is falling, something is soaking up the money. Before you sell a put and agree to own a stock, you want to know what.
Side by side
| Net income | Free cash flow | |
|---|---|---|
| Where to find it | Income statement, bottom line | Cash flow statement |
| What it counts | Sales minus costs, by accounting rules | Cash in from the business, minus spending on equipment |
| Sale on credit | Counts now | Counts when the customer pays |
| Unsold stock on shelves | Not a cost yet | Cash already spent |
| Depreciation | Subtracted | Added back (no cash left the bank) |
| New equipment | Spread over years | Subtracted the year it's bought |
| Easier to dress up? | Yes, with accounting choices | Harder, but not impossible |
The basic formula: free cash flow = cash from operations − capital spending. Cash from operations starts at net income and adjusts for everything that didn't move cash.
One company where they split
Here's a made-up company, Kestrel Tools (hypothetical, not a trade idea). Sales grew from $450 million to $500 million. Profit grew too. The headline looks great.
| Kestrel Tools | Last year | This year |
|---|---|---|
| Net income | $40M | $50M |
| Add back depreciation | +$20M | +$20M |
| Unpaid customer bills (change) | −$5M | −$45M |
| Unsold stock on shelves (change) | +$5M | −$25M |
| Cash from operations | $60M | $0 |
| Spending on equipment | −$25M | −$30M |
| Free cash flow | $35M | −$30M |
Check the math. This year: 50 + 20 − 45 − 25 = 0. Then 0 − 30 = −$30 million. Last year: 40 + 20 − 5 + 5 = 60, and 60 − 25 = $35 million.
Profit rose by $10 million. Free cash flow fell by $65 million. Two lines explain it:
- Customers owe $45 million more. Kestrel booked the sales, but it's waiting for the money. Maybe it gave buyers easy terms to hit a sales number.
- Inventory grew by $25 million. Kestrel made tools it hasn't sold. That cash is sitting in a warehouse.
As margins: net margin is 50 ÷ 500 = 10%. Free cash flow margin is −30 ÷ 500 = −6%.
Operating cash flow vs net income: the one-number check
Divide cash from operations by net income. The answer tells you how much cash each $1 of profit brought in.
| Kestrel Tools | Last year | This year |
|---|---|---|
| Cash from operations | $60M | $0 |
| Net income | $40M | $50M |
| Cash per $1 of profit | 60 ÷ 40 = 1.5 | 0 ÷ 50 = 0 |
Last year, each $1 of profit brought in $1.50 of cash. That's normal for a healthy company, since depreciation gets added back. This year, each $1 of profit brought in nothing.
Near 1 or above is what you want. Below 1 for a single year is a question. Below 1 year after year means the profit isn't turning into cash. If net income is negative, skip the ratio and read the cash line itself.
What it cost the put seller
Kestrel trades at $45. A trader looks at the rising profit and sells one 45-day cash-secured put at the $40 strike for $1.50 (hypothetical). That's $150 collected and $4,000 set aside. Break-even is $40 − $1.50 = $38.50.
Next quarter, Kestrel says two things. It will sell new shares to raise cash, and it's marking down the unsold tools. The stock falls to $30 by expiry.
| At expiry | What happens | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Stock at $30 | Assigned 100 shares at $40 | Shares worth $3,000 |
| Premium kept | +$150 | |
| Net | (30 − 38.50) × 100 | −$850 |
The warning was in the cash flow statement a quarter early. The income statement hid it. Selling the put meant saying "I'm happy to own this at $40." Free cash flow said Kestrel was running short of money.
Free cash flow can mislead too
Cash is harder to fake, but it can still flatter a company:
- Cutting equipment spending. A company can skip upkeep for a year. Free cash flow jumps, and the factory gets older.
- Paying suppliers late. Holding back bills makes cash look better for a while.
- Stock-based pay. Shares handed to staff aren't cash, so they're added back. Free cash flow looks bigger, but owners get diluted.
- One lumpy year. A big equipment purchase can make one good company look bad for a year.
So read three to five years, not one. A single year where the two split is a question. Several years in a row is an answer.
Pick which number, when
| Use this | When you want to know… |
|---|---|
| Net income | how profitable the business is by the rules |
| Net income | the P/E ratio and earnings growth |
| Free cash flow | whether it can pay its debt and dividend |
| Free cash flow | whether profit is turning into real money |
| Both, over years | whether you'd be happy to own it at the strike |
My options course teaches these together as one quality check: net margin, return on equity, sales growth, debt to equity, current ratio and free cash flow margin. The free version of the check is in quality checks before wheeling a stock, and gross margin vs net margin covers the profit side. To match a stock that passes with the right strategy, use the options strategy comparison chart.
Questions
Can a company have profit but no cash?
Yes. If customers pay slowly, stock piles up, or the company buys a lot of equipment, profit can be positive while cash goes out the door. It can't last forever, because bills are paid in cash.
Is negative free cash flow always bad?
No. A growing company may spend heavily on new factories for a few years. The question is whether the spending is a plan or a leak. Read the company's own explanation and look at several years.
Where do I find free cash flow?
Most stock sites show it. You can also work it out from the cash flow statement: cash from operating activities minus capital expenditures.
Which matters more for selling puts?
Both matter, but cash decides whether a company survives a bad patch without selling new shares or cutting its dividend. Those are the events that push a stock through your strike.
Follow along