Sharpe ratio vs Sortino ratio: what's the difference, and when do both lie?
The Sharpe ratio counts every swing, up or down, as risk. The Sortino ratio only counts the down months. Use Sortino when the ups are big and lumpy. Use Sharpe for a fair everyday comparison. Trust neither on a short, smooth record, because a risk that hasn't happened yet doesn't show up in either.
The short answer
Both ratios ask: how much did you earn for each unit of bumpiness?
- Sharpe ratio: the average return divided by how much returns swing around, up and down (the Standard deviation).
- Sortino ratio: the average return divided by the swing of the down months only (called downside deviation).
Higher is better for both. Sortino is kinder to a record with big up months, since it doesn't count those as risk. Sharpe treats a surprise gain and a surprise loss the same.
Both only see the months you give them. A strategy that wins small for a long time and then loses big all at once can score beautifully on both, right up to the bad month.
Side by side
| Sharpe ratio | Sortino ratio | |
|---|---|---|
| What counts as risk | All swings, up and down | Only down months |
| Punishes a big up month | Yes | No |
| With no losing months | A big number | Can't be worked out (divide by zero) |
| Most common in fund reports | Yes | Less often |
| Best for | Comparing two records fairly | Records with lumpy gains |
| Sees a disaster that hasn't happened | No | No |
A good year, then one bad month (hypothetical)
Picture an option seller who collects premiums every month. Most months win, and a few lose a little. Here are two versions of the same year. Version B is the same, except the last month goes badly.
| Month | Version A | Version B |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | +2.0% | +2.0% |
| 2 | −1.0% | −1.0% |
| 3 | +1.5% | +1.5% |
| 4 | +1.0% | +1.0% |
| 5 | +2.5% | +2.5% |
| 6 | −2.0% | −2.0% |
| 7 | +1.5% | +1.5% |
| 8 | +1.0% | +1.0% |
| 9 | −0.5% | −0.5% |
| 10 | +2.0% | +2.0% |
| 11 | +1.0% | +1.0% |
| 12 | +1.5% | −12.0% |
| $10,000 becomes | $11,091 | $9,616 (−$384) |
To keep the math simple, I set the cash rate to zero. Real reports subtract a cash rate first. The swing of all months is the usual standard deviation (the spreadsheet STDEV, which divides by 11). Both ratios are turned into yearly numbers by multiplying the monthly figure by about 3.46 (the square root of 12).
| Version A | Version B | |
|---|---|---|
| Average month | +0.88% | −0.25% |
| Swing of all months | 1.35% | 3.93% |
| Swing of down months only | 0.66% | 3.53% |
| Sharpe ratio | 2.2 | −0.22 |
| Sortino ratio | 4.6 | −0.25 |
How the downside swing works: square each down month, add them up, divide by all 12 months, then take the square root. In Version A the down months are −1.0, −2.0 and −0.5. Squared, that's 1 + 4 + 0.25 = 5.25. Divided by 12, it's about 0.44, and the square root is about 0.66. The Sortino is 0.88 ÷ 0.66, times 3.46, about 4.6.
The seller's trap
Version A looks great. A Sharpe above 2 is what many people call very good. The Sortino of 4.6 looks even better, because the three down months were small.
Then month 12 lands. One month wipes out the whole year and more, and both ratios go negative.
Nothing about the strategy changed in month 12. The risk was always there. It just hadn't shown up yet. Selling options, especially naked or with big size, often looks like Version A for a long time: many small wins, rare big losses. Ratios built on a short, smooth record can't see the big loss coming. They only measure the bumps that already happened.
My guide to drawdown math for option sellers shows what it takes to climb back from a month like that.
Which one to use
| Lean on Sharpe if… | Lean on Sortino if… |
|---|---|
| You're comparing two funds the usual way | The record has big up months you don't want punished |
| Gains and losses are both fairly even | You care most about how bad the drops are |
| You want the number most reports use | You're comparing two records with the same losses |
And for either one:
- Ask how many years the record covers, and whether it includes a bad market.
- Look at the worst month and the Max drawdown, the biggest drop from a high, next to the ratio.
- Be most careful when the ratio is very high and the record is short. That's often a strategy whose bad month hasn't come yet.
The options strategy comparison chart shows the worst case of each option strategy up front, which is the number these ratios can miss.
Questions
Is a higher Sortino ratio always better than a higher Sharpe ratio?
You can't compare one against the other. Sortino is usually higher on the same record, because it only counts down months. Compare Sortino with Sortino and Sharpe with Sharpe.
What is a good Sharpe ratio?
Many people treat 1 as decent and 2 as very good over several years. A very high number on a short record is a reason to look closer, not to relax.
Why can't you work out Sortino with no losing months?
The bottom of the fraction is the swing of the down months. With none, it's zero, and you can't divide by zero. That tells you the record is too short or too smooth to judge.
Do Sharpe and Sortino work for option selling?
They can mislead. Option selling often wins small and loses big, rarely. A record without a big loss in it will score far better than the strategy deserves.
Follow along