Home › Comparisons

TSLY or your own covered calls on Tesla: which trade are you really making?

TSLY runs a covered-call-style trade on Tesla for you, starting at one fund share. Doing it yourself needs 100 shares, but you pick the strike, the date and the weeks to sit out. A drop followed by a rally shows why that matters.

Comparison · 7-minute read · Updated 2026-10-28

The short answer

TSLY is a YieldMax fund built on Tesla (TSLA). As of October 2026, it doesn't hold Tesla shares. It copies the stock's moves with options, sells call spreads on top, and pays out most of the premium.

Selling covered calls on Tesla yourself means owning 100 TSLA shares and selling one Call option against them, at a strike and date you choose.

Both take nearly the full drop. Both give up part of a big rally. The fund is easy to start. Doing it yourself costs more to start but gives you every choice. This isn't a recommendation to buy or sell TSLY or Tesla.

As of October 2026, TSLY's fund page says it sells call spreads on Tesla and pays weekly. A spread keeps some upside above its higher strike, so the real cap is a bit looser than the plain call in our example. The method can change, so check TSLY's current page. The general build is in how YieldMax ETFs work.

Side by side

Capital per contract

One call covers 100 shares. Here's what that means at made-up Tesla prices. Check the real price today.

Tesla's options are very actively traded, so prices are easy to get. But the stock moves a lot, especially around its quarterly earnings. That's why its calls pay well, and why 100 shares can swing by thousands in a week.

A big drop, worked out (hypothetical)

This is an illustration, not a trade idea, and it isn't TSLY's real trades. A made-up TSLA price starts at $400. Three people each have $40,000 at stake.

• The shareholder holds 100 shares.
• The do-it-yourself seller holds 100 shares and sells one 30-day $440 call for $20, collecting $2,000.
• The fund holder has $40,000 in a made-up fund that sells a new call every week, a hypothetical schedule, collecting $700 each time.

Tesla falls to $300 over the month.

Everyone loses big. The premium covered less than a third of the drop. In a pure fall, the fund's weekly premiums even help a little.

Then a big rally (hypothetical)

Now Tesla rips back from $300 to $390 in two weeks, then sits there.

The do-it-yourself seller chooses a $400 call, right at their own cost, for $8: $800. The stock ends below $400, so the call expires. They keep the whole climb.

The fund keeps selling calls a little above each week's price.

Tesla ended $10 below where it started. The fund holder is down more than the shareholder. The fund took the full drop, then capped the two biggest weeks of the bounce.

The do-it-yourself seller came out ahead only because of choices: a strike at their cost, picked after the drop. Pick a $320 strike instead, and they'd have been capped too. Part of the fund's loss reaches you as payouts and part as a lower share price. That's NAV erosion.

What you control, and what you don't

Doing it yourself, you decide:

• the strike, above your cost or not;
• the date, around or away from earnings;
• whether to sell at all after a sharp drop.

You don't control the stock. A 25% drop costs the same either way. That's why the share size comes first, before any call. The same order runs through the wheel strategy. For how TSLY compares with index funds like JEPI, see how covered call ETFs work.

Canadian readers: covered calls are widely allowed in a TFSA or RRSP, but options permissions differ by broker. A US-listed fund held in a TFSA can lose part of its payouts to US withholding tax; see US covered call ETFs in a TFSA.

Questions