Home › Guides › Options: covered calls

Should you sell a covered call or just sell the stock?

If you'd be happy to sell your shares near today's price, a covered call at that price can pay you while you wait. If you want out because something is wrong, sell the stock. A call only pays a small amount, and the shares stay at risk until they're gone.

Options guide · 8-minute read · Updated 2026-10-27

The short answer

A Covered call can work as a slow exit: you name a sale price, get paid a premium, and wait to see if the stock gets there. Selling the stock is a fast exit: you're out today, at today's price, with no premium and no more risk.

Which one fits depends on why you want out.

• "I'd be glad to sell around this price, but I'm not in a hurry." The call can fit.
• "Something has changed and I don't want to own this." Sell the stock.

The slow exit, worked out (an illustration, not a trade idea)

You bought 100 shares of a made-up stock, XYZ, at $40. It's now $50. You're up $1,000, and you'd be happy to sell at $50.

Choice 1: sell today. You get $5,000. You lock in +$1,000. Done.

Choice 2: sell a 30-day $50 call (at today's price) for $1.50. You collect $150 and wait.

Read the right-hand column. At $50 or above, the call adds $150 to your exit. Below $48.50, you'd have been better off selling. And if XYZ falls far, you still own it, with the $1,000 gain mostly gone.

So the call pays you to accept two risks: the stock might fall before you sell, and you give up anything above $50.

Making the exit more likely

If you want the sale to happen, you can sell a call below today's price. That's an in-the-money call. It's more likely to be exercised.

Say you sell a 30-day $48 call for $2.80. If XYZ ends above $48, you sell at $48 + $2.80 = $50.80 a share, about $80 more than selling today. If XYZ drops to $45, you keep the shares: +$500 + $280 = +$780, which is −$220 compared with selling today.

The deeper in the money, the more it behaves like a sale, and the less extra it pays. See in-the-money covered calls.

One caution: a call that's in the money can be exercised before expiry, especially just before an Ex-dividend date. You might be out sooner than you planned. That's usually fine on a slow exit.

When the call is a good slow exit

• You're happy to sell at the strike. Not "it's fine," but genuinely glad.
• The business hasn't changed. You're exiting because you reached your price, not because something broke.
• No earnings before expiry. A report could gap the stock far below your strike overnight.
• You don't need the cash soon. The money stays tied up until the call ends.
• A small extra is worth the wait to you. $150 on a $5,000 position, in the example.

When it isn't

• The story changed. Bad news, a cut forecast, a reason you'd never buy it today. A call doesn't get you out; it keeps you in for another month.
• You need the money. Selling today puts the cash in your account in a day or so. A call might never be exercised.
• The stock is falling fast. The premium looks bigger, but the slide can take far more than it pays. See covered calls on a stock in free fall.
• You're down, not up. If you're exiting at a loss, a call at your exit price is often below your cost. See covered calls on a losing stock.
• Earnings or big news is coming. If you don't want to hold through it, sell before it.

A split exit

With 200 shares or more, you don't have to choose one. Sell half today, and sell a call on the rest. You lock in part of the gain, and get paid to wait on the other part.

That's a common middle path. It also fits the wheel strategy, where being called away is simply the end of one cycle and the start of the next put.

Taxes can change the answer

Selling today and being called away later can land in different tax years, or on different sides of the one-year mark for long-term gains. In a taxable account, that can matter more than the premium. This is general information, not tax advice; check with a tax professional or your broker. See covered call taxes.

In a TFSA, RRSP or IRA, gains inside the account generally aren't taxed year by year, so the choice is mostly about price and risk. In Canada, options permissions differ by broker.

Questions