Home › Guides › Options: decisions

Should you run the wheel by hand or automate it?

Automate the boring parts of the wheel: reminders, cash math, journal entries and buy-back orders. Keep the judgment calls by hand: which stock, how big, and what to do when news hits. And write your rules down before you hand any of them to software.

Options guide · 8-minute read · Updated 2026-10-27

The short answer

The wheel strategy is a loop of small, repeated steps. Many of those steps are pure routine: checking dates, adding up cash, logging trades, placing a buy-back order. Software is good at routine.

Some steps aren't routine at all. Which stock is still worth owning after bad news? Should this put be rolled or taken? Is the account too concentrated? Those depend on context a simple rule can miss.

So the honest split is: automate the checks and the paperwork, keep the decisions. And before you automate anything, write the rule down in plain words. You can't automate a rule you haven't made.

What you can hand to software

What should stay in your hands

The decisions that need you are the ones where the "why" matters.

• A stock that dropped. Software sees a lower price and a bigger premium. You can see that the drop came from a cut outlook and the business has changed.
• An event in the calendar. A screen might list the earnings date. It takes a person to decide whether a trade over that date is worth the gap risk.
• A bad month. When three positions go wrong at once, the right move may be to stop selling for a while. Most rules don't know how to stop.

A rule that runs without you will also run when it shouldn't.

A worked example: the rule that wasn't written (an illustration, not a trade idea)

Say you set up a bot with one rule:

For five weeks it works. Then in week six, the highest premium on your list belongs to a made-up stock, XYZ, at $44. It pays the most because XYZ reports earnings on Wednesday. The bot sells a $40 put for $1.50 ($150) and sets aside $4,000.

XYZ misses badly and opens at $28.

The bot did exactly what it was told. The problem was the missing rule. A person running a written checklist would likely have skipped XYZ, because "is there earnings inside the expiry?" is on it.

Now flip it. Write that rule into the bot and it will check the date every time, which a tired person sometimes forgets. That's the real lesson: software is only as good as the rules you've already worked out by hand.

The risks of letting software trade

If you do let a program place trades, know the extra risks. Some brokers offer ways to connect software to your account; check the broker's current help pages for what's allowed.

• Bugs. A typo in a rule can sell ten contracts instead of one.
• Bad fills. A program using market orders pays the full spread every time. See limit vs market orders.
• Outages. If the program, your connection or the broker goes down, open positions are left with nobody watching.
• No sense of the whole account. A rule that checks one trade at a time can pile up five puts in one sector. See one position or several.
• Speed. When something goes wrong, it goes wrong for every trade at once.

None of this makes automation bad. It means a person should check every trade a program places, at least until the rules have survived some rough months.

Rules first, then tools

Here's a path that works for most people:

1. Run the wheel by hand for a while. Paper trades count. Write down every step you take and why.
2. Turn the steps into a checklist. Earnings date, ex-dividend date, cash committed, strike vs cost basis, spread, size.
3. Automate the checklist's data. Reminders for dates, a sheet that adds up cash, alerts near strikes.
4. Automate the orders that can't hurt you. Buy-back orders at a profit target, for example.
5. Keep new trades and big decisions manual, or at least approved by you before they go in.

A simple journal makes all of this easier. Our wheel strategy tracking spreadsheet page shows the columns that matter.

In Canada and the US, the same split applies in any account. Options permissions and tools differ by broker, so check what yours offers before you plan around it.

Questions