Home › Guides › Options: the wheel

The wheel in a bear market: what happens when the stock keeps falling

In a bear market, the wheel turns into owning stocks that keep falling. Puts get assigned, calls pay less and less, and the premiums only soften the drop. Here is the math, and the rules that keep it small.

Options guide · 8-minute read · Updated 2026-10-26

What a bear market does to the wheel

In a falling market, the wheel strategy gets stuck on its first leg. The puts you sell get assigned, because the stock drops below the strike. Then you hold shares that keep losing value.

The premiums you collect are real. But they are small next to the drop. A bear market is when the wheel shows what it truly is: owning stock, with a small fee paid to you along the way.

One stock, four months down (an illustration, not a trade idea)

A made-up stock, XYZ, trades at $50. You sell a 30-day $45 Put option for $1.00 and collect $100. Your broker sets aside $4,500.

Then the market turns. XYZ closes month one at $42. You are assigned. You now own 100 shares at $45, and your cost after the premium is $44.

You sell Covered calls at $45 so you don't lock in a loss. With the stock far below that strike, the premium keeps shrinking.

Four months, four premiums, $170 collected. The shares lost $1,500 below the strike. The open loss is −$1,330.

Someone who bought 100 shares at $50 on day one is down $2,000. So the wheel did better. But "better than a $2,000 loss" is still a $1,330 loss. The premium softened the fall. It did not stop it.

Why the premiums shrink as the stock falls

A call's price depends a lot on how close the strike is to the stock. At $38, a $45 call is far away, so buyers pay little for it. At $30, it is nearly worthless.

That leaves two choices, and both hurt:

1. Keep the strike at or above your cost. You collect almost nothing, but you won't sell at a loss.
2. Drop the strike near the price for a bigger premium. If the stock bounces, your shares get called away below your cost.

Say in month 4 you sell a $32 call for $1.00 instead of the $45 call. Your cost going in is $43.40. XYZ bounces to $36. Your shares are called away at $32. Your result: ($32 − $43.40) × 100 + $100 = −$1,040, now locked in for good. That is the strike-below-cost trap.

Five puts at once

A bear market rarely hits one stock. It hits most of them together.

Say you had $25,000 and sold five puts on five stocks, each tying up $4,500. That is $22,500 set aside. In a broad drop, all five can be assigned in the same month. If each stock ends 30% under its strike, the shares lose about $1,350 each, or $6,750 in total. Five premiums of $100 bring that to −$6,250.

You now hold five falling stocks and almost no spare cash. That is the real bear-market danger: not one bad trade, but the whole account stuck at once. See the market crashed while I had five puts open.

The rules that limit the drawdown

A drawdown is how far your account falls from its high point. You can't stop it in a bear market. You can decide its size in advance.

• Size each put as a share purchase. Only sell a put if you'd buy those 100 shares today with that cash.
• Cap one name. Keep any one stock to a small slice of the account, so one collapse can't sink it.
• Keep cash unused. Don't set aside every dollar. Spare cash is what lets you wait.
• Pick an exit for the shares before you sell the put. Write down the price where you'd sell the stock, and what that loss would be. See assigned and the stock kept falling.
• No calls below your cost unless you accept the loss. Decide that on purpose, not for a bigger premium.
• No new puts on names you already hold. In a falling market, adding more of the same stock doubles the risk.

Questions