ATR stop vs percentage stop: which one fits the way your stock moves?
A percentage stop sits the same distance away no matter how the stock is moving. An ATR stop stretches and shrinks with the stock's normal daily swing. Use ATR when the stock's mood changes a lot. Use a percentage when you want one simple rule and the stock moves about the same every month.
The short answer
A percentage stop sells if the price falls a set percent below where you bought, like 5%.
An ATR stop uses the ATR, or average true range. That's how far the stock has moved in a typical day lately, usually over the last 14 days. A "2x ATR stop" sits two normal days' worth of movement below your entry.
The percentage stop ignores how the stock is acting. In a calm month it's often too far away. In a wild month it's often too close, and normal noise knocks you out. The ATR stop adjusts to both.
Side by side
| Percentage stop | ATR stop | |
|---|---|---|
| Distance from entry | Fixed, like 5% | Changes with daily swings |
| In a calm month | Often wider than needed | Tighter |
| In a wild month | Often hit by noise | Wider |
| Position size at the same risk | Same every month | Bigger when calm, smaller when wild |
| Easy to work out | Very | Needs the ATR number |
| Knows about the chart | No | No, it only knows the swing size |
Neither one knows where the last real turning point on the chart is. Many traders check that first, then use ATR to make sure the stop isn't inside the normal daily wiggle. My guide on how to set a stop loss covers that step.
One stock, two months (hypothetical)
You have a $20,000 account and risk 1% on a trade, so $200. The stock is at $100.
To size the trade, divide the $200 by the distance to your stop. That's the part people skip: the stop sets the size.
| Calm month (ATR $1) | Wild month (ATR $4) | |
|---|---|---|
| 5% stop | $95, $5 away | $95, $5 away |
| Shares at $200 risk | 40 ($4,000) | 40 ($4,000) |
| 2x ATR stop | $98, $2 away | $92, $8 away |
| Shares at $200 risk | 100 ($10,000) | 25 ($2,500) |
In the calm month, the 5% stop is five normal days away. To keep risk at $200, you can only buy 40 shares. The ATR stop lets you hold 100 shares for the same $200 risk.
In the wild month, the stock moves $4 on a normal day. A $5 stop is barely more than one ordinary day. The ATR stop sits $8 away, and you buy fewer shares to pay for that room.
Four endings, same $200 risk
| What happened | 5% stop | 2x ATR stop |
|---|---|---|
| Calm month, rises to $105 | +$200 (40 sh) | +$500 (100 sh) |
| Calm month, slides to $94 | −$200 | −$200 |
| Wild month, dips to $94.50, then rises to $105 | −$200 (stopped out) | +$125 (25 sh) |
| Wild month, drops to $90 | −$200 | −$200 |
Check the rows. When a stop is hit, both lose $200, because the size was set so they would. That's the point of sizing from the stop.
The third row is the losing case for the percentage stop. A normal wild-month dip took it out at $95, and then the stock went where you thought it would. The ATR stop sat through the same dip.
The first row is the cost of a too-wide stop. The trade worked, but the percentage stop only let you hold 40 shares, so you made less on the same idea.
One thing neither stop fixes: a gap. If the stock opens far below your stop, a stop order sells at the next price it can get, which can be well under your level. The real loss can be bigger than $200.
Pick a percentage stop if… pick an ATR stop if…
| Pick a percentage stop if… | Pick an ATR stop if… |
|---|---|
| You want one rule with no math | The stock's daily swing changes a lot |
| The stock moves about the same each month | You keep getting stopped out by noise |
| You trade long-term and check rarely | You size each trade from a set dollar risk |
| You're just starting and need simple | You trade many stocks with different moods |
Whichever you pick, set the size from the stop, not the other way round. Fixed fractional vs fixed dollar shows how to pick the dollar risk itself, and the position size calculator does the division for you. Our ATR guide shows how the number is worked out.
When you're ready to look past stocks, the options strategy comparison chart shows how option sellers set their worst case before the trade.
Questions
What is a good ATR multiple for a stop loss?
Many traders use somewhere between 1.5 and 3 times ATR. Smaller gets hit by noise more often. Bigger means fewer shares for the same dollar risk. Test it on past charts of your own stocks.
Is a 5% stop loss good?
It depends on the stock. For a stock that moves 1% a day, 5% is a lot of room. For one that moves 4% a day, it's barely one normal day. Compare it with the ATR first.
Does an ATR stop move as the trade goes on?
You choose. Some traders set it once at entry. Others trail it, moving it up as price rises. A trailing ATR stop only moves up, never down.
Where do I find ATR?
Most charting apps have it as an indicator, often with 14 days as the default. It shows the average daily range in dollars, not percent.
Follow along