Fixed fractional vs fixed dollar sizing: what happens in a losing streak?
Fixed fractional risks a set percent of what's in the account right now, so your bets shrink as you lose. Fixed dollar risks the same amount every time. Fixed fractional is the safer default for most traders, because a long losing streak can never take the account to zero.
The short answer
Fixed fractional sizing means you risk the same percent of your current balance on every trade, like 2%. Lose, and the next bet is a little smaller. Win, and it grows.
Fixed dollar sizing means you risk the same dollar amount on every trade, like $200, no matter what the balance is.
In a losing streak, fixed fractional loses less, because each bet shrinks. In the recovery, fixed dollar comes back faster, because its bets didn't shrink. Over a long bad run, only fixed fractional can't hit zero.
"Risk" here means what you lose if your stop is hit. It's not the size of the position. See how much to risk per trade for how the two connect.
Side by side
| Fixed fractional (2%) | Fixed dollar ($200) | |
|---|---|---|
| Risk on the next trade | 2% of today's balance | $200, always |
| After losses | Bets shrink | Bets stay the same |
| After wins | Bets grow | Bets stay the same |
| Long losing streak | Slows the fall, never reaches zero | Same speed all the way down |
| Coming back from a dip | Slower | Faster |
| Math each trade | A quick percent | None |
A 10-loss streak, then 5 wins (hypothetical)
Two traders each start with $10,000. Both lose 10 trades in a row, then win 5 in a row. Each win is twice the size of the risk.
- Trader A risks 2% of the current balance.
- Trader B risks $200 every time, which is 2% of the starting balance.
| Trade | A's result | A's balance | B's result | B's balance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | −$200.00 | $9,800.00 | −$200 | $9,800 |
| 2 | −$196.00 | $9,604.00 | −$200 | $9,600 |
| 3 | −$192.08 | $9,411.92 | −$200 | $9,400 |
| 4 | −$188.24 | $9,223.68 | −$200 | $9,200 |
| 5 | −$184.47 | $9,039.21 | −$200 | $9,000 |
| 6 | −$180.79 | $8,858.42 | −$200 | $8,800 |
| 7 | −$177.16 | $8,681.26 | −$200 | $8,600 |
| 8 | −$173.63 | $8,507.63 | −$200 | $8,400 |
| 9 | −$170.15 | $8,337.48 | −$200 | $8,200 |
| 10 | −$166.75 | $8,170.73 | −$200 | $8,000 |
| 11 | +$326.83 | $8,497.56 | +$400 | $8,400 |
| 12 | +$339.90 | $8,837.46 | +$400 | $8,800 |
| 13 | +$353.50 | $9,190.96 | +$400 | $9,200 |
| 14 | +$367.64 | $9,558.60 | +$400 | $9,600 |
| 15 | +$382.34 | $9,940.94 | +$400 | $10,000 |
At the bottom, after trade 10, Trader A is down −$1,829.27 and Trader B is down −$2,000. Fixed fractional saved about $171 in the streak.
Then the wins. Each of B's wins adds $400. Each of A's wins adds 4% of a smaller balance. B is back to $10,000 after five wins. A is still −$59.06 short.
So neither method is free. Fixed fractional pays for its cushion with a slower climb back.
Where the real difference shows up
Ten losses is a small streak next to what can happen. Run the same two traders through 50 losses in a row:
- Trader B loses $200 fifty times. That's $10,000. The account is at $0.
- Trader A keeps shrinking the bet. After 50 losses the account is about $3,642. Bruised, but still able to trade.
Fifty losses in a row is rare. But a fixed-dollar plan doesn't have to hit zero to hurt. If the account drops by half, $200 is now 4% of it, and the same streak does twice the damage. Fixed dollar quietly gets riskier as you lose. The losing streak calculator shows how likely a streak is for your win rate.
Can you mix them?
Yes, and many traders do. A common version: risk a fixed dollar amount, and reset it once a month or once a quarter to a percent of the balance at that time. You get easy math trade to trade, and the bet still shrinks after a bad month.
Another fix for fixed dollar: a rule to cut the amount after a set Drawdown, the drop from your account's high point. For example, halve the dollar risk if the account falls 10% from its peak.
Pick fixed fractional if… pick fixed dollar if…
| Pick fixed fractional if… | Fixed dollar can fit if… |
|---|---|
| You want a long streak to slow itself down | You reset the amount on a schedule |
| You can do one percent sum per trade | You have a rule to cut it after a drawdown |
| You're sizing a small account | You want the same number on every trade |
| You want risk to grow only as the account grows | Your account is large next to each bet |
For most people starting out, fixed fractional at a small percent is the safer default. If you've heard of the Kelly formula, Kelly criterion vs fixed fractional shows why a formula that picks the percent for you can go badly wrong.
Curious how option sellers size trades with a known worst case? The options strategy comparison chart puts the max loss of each strategy side by side.
Questions
What is fixed fractional position sizing?
You risk the same percent of your current account balance on each trade, like 1% or 2%. The dollar amount changes as the balance goes up and down.
Is fixed dollar risk bad?
Not on its own. The problem is that it doesn't shrink after losses, so it gets riskier as the account falls. Resetting the amount on a schedule fixes most of that.
Why does fixed fractional recover slower?
After losses, each bet is smaller, so each win is smaller too. The same cushion that slowed the fall slows the climb back.
What percent should I risk with fixed fractional?
Many traders use 0.5% to 2% per trade. Run your worst likely losing streak through that number first, and pick a percent whose drop you could live with.
Follow along