How to review your trades and find your mistakes
Review once a week. Count your results in R, tag each trade's mistake, find the one that costs the most, and fix only that.
The short answer
To review your trades, wait until the week ends, then spend 15 minutes on four steps: count your results in R, tag every trade as rules followed or broken, give each broken one a single mistake label, and pick the one mistake that cost you the most. Fix only that one next week. Judge each trade by your plan, not by whether it made money.
Why you review weekly, not after every trade
One trade tells you almost nothing. It can win by luck or lose with a perfect plan. A week of trades shows a pattern.
Reviewing right after a trade has a second problem. You are still angry or happy. A weekly review is calm. You read the rows like a coach would.
Pick a fixed time. Friday night or Sunday morning works. Put it in your calendar like a class.
What you need
A log with one row per trade. If you don't have one, start with how to keep a trading journal and grab the free journal CSV. It has the two columns this review runs on: "Followed my rules?" and "Mistake."
Two words you will use:
- R-multiple: your result measured in units of risk. A trade stopped out is -1R. A trade that makes twice your risk is +2R.
- Mistake label: one short tag for what went wrong, such as "early exit" or "moved stop."
The 15-minute routine
- Count (3 minutes). Total trades. Wins and losses. Win rate. Average R per trade. Total R for the week.
- Split by rules (3 minutes). Count the trades where you followed your plan and the ones where you broke it. Work out the average R for each group.
- Label (4 minutes). Give every broken-rule trade one mistake label. Use the same short list every week (see the table below). Only one label per trade.
- Tally (2 minutes). Count each label. Add up the R each label produced.
- Pick one fix (2 minutes). Choose the label with the worst total R. Write one sentence: "Next week I will ___."
- Write it at the top of next week's page. You will see it before your first trade.
Judge the trade by the plan. A losing trade where you followed the rules is a good trade. A winning trade where you broke the rules is a bad one that got lucky. Don't fix the first. Do fix the second.
A starter list of mistake labels
Keep your list short. Five to seven labels is plenty.
| Label | What it means | Plain example |
|---|---|---|
| Early entry | Entered before your signal finished | Bought before the candle closed |
| Late entry | Chased price after it moved | Bought far from your level |
| Early exit | Closed before your target or stop | Sold at +0.5R, plan said +2R |
| Moved stop | Changed your stop to avoid a loss | Widened it, lost 2R not 1R |
| Too big | Position size above your plan | Risked double |
| No plan | No setup written before entry | "It looked good" |
Add a seventh, "skipped," for good trades you didn't take. Those belong in the log too.
Worked example: 20 trades, one clear fix
This is made-up data, rounded to keep the math easy. It is not a real account.
Say you took 20 practice trades over a few weeks. You tagged each one. Here is the tally:
| Tag | Trades | Total R | Average R |
|---|---|---|---|
| Followed plan, no mistake | 12 | +3.0 | +0.25 |
| Early exit | 6 | +3.0 | +0.50 |
| Moved stop | 2 | -4.0 | -2.00 |
| All 20 trades | 20 | +2.0 | +0.10 |
Here is how those rows add up:
- The 12 clean trades: 5 wins at +2R is +10R, and 7 losses at -1R is -7R. That is +3.0R.
- The 6 early exits each closed at +0.5R. That is +3.0R.
- The 2 moved stops each lost 2R instead of the planned 1R. That is -4.0R.
- Total: 3.0 + 3.0 - 4.0 = +2.0R over 20 trades, or +0.10R per trade. Wins: 5 + 6 = 11, so a win rate of 55%.
Now split by rules. The 12 clean trades averaged +0.25R. The 8 trades with a mistake had a total of -1.0R, an average of -0.125R. Following the plan is where the edge was.
Which mistake do you fix? Early exit is the most common, with 6 trades. But it made money. Moved stop happened twice and erased two-thirds of the gain from the other 18 trades (+6.0R down to +2.0R). The costly one is not always the common one. The fix is: "I never touch a stop once I'm in."
Early exits go on the watch list. Plan target was +2R and these averaged +0.5R, so there may be room to improve. Fix them next, after the stop habit holds for a week or two.
How to find the pattern behind a mistake
A label tells you what. Now ask when. Look at the "How I felt" and "Notes" columns for the rows with that label.
- Did the moved stops all come after a loss?
- Did the early exits happen when you felt nervous?
- Were they all at the same time of day or on the same setup?
If you see a link, write it into your fix. "After a loss, I walk away for 10 minutes before the next trade" is stronger than "Don't move my stop."
What makes a fix work
- One fix at a time. Five fixes at once means none stick.
- Make it a thing you can see. "Stop stays where I put it" can be checked on every trade. "Be more disciplined" can't.
- Check it next week. Did the label count go down? If yes, keep it for one more week, then move to the next one.
Once you have 30 or more trades, the expectancy calculator can turn your win rate and average win and loss into an average result per trade.
Where StructureX fits
In the StructureX trade journal, you log results in R and mark whether you followed your rules and what error you made. The analytics screen then shows win rate, average R, total R and rule adherence, and breaks them down by setup and by mistake. Once a view has at least 5 trades, "Analyze with AI" can write a short report from those numbers. The pre-trade checklist is yours to customize, so the rules you review against are the rules you wrote.
What to read next
If you want a full set of questions to ask yourself, see journaling prompts for traders. To let an AI read your log, use how to use AI to review your trading journal. When the week was just bad, how to handle a losing streak helps. To build a day around all this, see trading routine. For the unit behind it all, read R-multiple and the trading plan review checklist.
Questions
How often should I review my trades?
Once a week is a good start. One trade is too small a sample, and a month waits too long to fix a habit.
How many trades do I need before a review means anything?
A weekly review still helps with as few as five or ten trades, because the rules-followed check works on any number. Treat patterns in small samples as hints, and confirm them over more weeks.
What if I lost money but followed my rules?
That is a normal week. Losses are part of any plan. Check that your stop, size and entry matched the plan, and move on. Change the plan only after a longer run of trades, not one bad week.
What is the difference between a mistake and a bad trade?
A mistake is something you did that broke your plan, like moving a stop. A bad trade is just one that lost. You can lose on a perfect trade. You can win on a mistake.
Should I fix every mistake I find?
No. Pick the one with the worst total R and fix only that for a week. Small, steady fixes stick better than a big overhaul.
Do I need software to do this?
No. A spreadsheet works. The free CSV template has the columns, and a calculator is enough for the totals.
Follow along