Home › Guides › Books

The New Trading for a Living summary: Elder's 5 key ideas, in plain words

Most books cover charts, or psychology, or risk. This one says you need all three, and that the weakest one decides how things go.

Beginner guide · 6-minute read · Updated 2026-10-21

The book in one line

The New Trading for a Living is by Dr. Alexander Elder, a psychiatrist turned trader and teacher. It came out in 2014 as a revised, expanded version of his 1993 classic Trading for a Living.

In the update, Elder kept most of the psychology, trimmed some technical chapters, added newer tools, and rewrote the money-management section, which he said was the weakest part of the original.

The 5 ideas worth keeping

1. Mind, method, money

Elder's frame is three Ms:

• Mind — your psychology and discipline.
• Method — how you read the market and choose trades.
• Money — how much you risk and how you protect your account.

His point is that most people spend all their time on method. But a great method with poor risk rules, or a shaky mind, still breaks down. Work on all three.

2. The 2% rule: limit any single loss

Elder's first money rule: never risk more than 2% of your account on one trade. You decide the stop first, then size the trade so a stop-out costs no more than that.

Many educators, ourselves included, suggest about 1% for beginners, to keep losses even smaller while you learn. The number matters less than the habit: a fixed slice, every time. Work it out with the position size calculator.

3. The 6% rule: limit a bad month

His second rule protects you from a bad streak. If your account falls 6% below where it started the month, you stop opening new trades until the next month.

It's the same idea as our daily loss limit (2 losses and you're done for the day), stretched over a longer period. Both stop a bad run from turning into a disaster.

4. Look at more than one timeframe: the triple screen

Elder's best-known method is the triple screen. In short: use a longer-term chart to choose the direction, a shorter one to find a pullback against it, and an even shorter view to time the entry.

You don't need his exact indicators to use the idea. Check the bigger chart first and trade with it. Our multiple timeframe analysis guide shows a simple version.

5. Keep records, and grade yourself

Elder pushes hard for a trading diary: screenshots of the chart at entry and exit, the reason for the trade, and a grade for how well you followed your plan.

He argues that good records separate people who improve from people who repeat the same mistakes. See how to keep a trading journal for a simple template.

How to use it as a beginner

This is a big, wide book. Here's a practical way to use it:

1. Start with the psychology and money sections. They're the most useful for beginners.
2. Write the 2% rule (or 1%) and the 6% rule into your trading plan today.
3. Skim the indicator chapters. Pick at most one or two tools to learn later.
4. Try the triple screen idea on past charts with bar replay, and log every practice trade.

Who it's for, and who should skip it

It's for you if you want one book that covers psychology, charts and risk together, and you like clear, structured advice.

Skip it (for now) if you're overwhelmed by indicators. Parts of the method section cover many tools. A shorter guide like risk management for beginners may suit you better first.

A note on the title: "for a living" is the book's name, not a goal we'd set for anyone starting out. Most people learn trading alongside a job, and that's a sensible way to begin.

Read it with…

• Market Wizards: see how real traders put mind, method and money together in very different ways.
• Technical Analysis of the Financial Markets: more depth on the chart tools Elder uses.

Questions